Review: PHOENIX EXTRAVAGANT by Yoon Ha Lee


It took me a little while to be convinced I needed to read this book. Not because I didn’t think it sounded good, just because I didn’t know much about it and hadn’t felt particularly compelled to find out. Then I read Jake’s review on Jake Is Reading and was immediately compelled by the premise of the magic system. Now I’m not one of those readers who finds magic systems particularly interesting; I’m one of those weird fantasy readers for whom the magic is actually the least interesting thing about any given fantasy book, but the magic of PHOENIX EXTRAVAGANT really interested me.



The story is based on the Japanese occupation of Korea and follows Gyen Jebi, an unemployed artist in the occupied nation of Hwaguk. Jebi isn’t a nationalist or a rebel, or a fighter of any description, they just want to paint. But after staking everything on a prestigious and expensive art exam to work in the Razani bureaucracy they instead find themself drafted into the Ministry of Armor to paint the mystical sigils that animate the occupying government’s automaton soldiers. But there they hear tales of a massacre, a horrifying crime committed by the occupiers, and when they discover the source of the magical pigments used to power the automatons they find they can no longer remain neutral. What they can do though, is steal Arazi, the ministry’s mighty dragon automaton, and find a way to fight.

I’m gonna talk a little bit about the magic system, cos that was the most interesting thing about this book for me. Be aware the source of the magic could be considered spoiler territory for some people, but for me I probs wouldn’t have read this book if I hadn’t known beforehand, so I leave you to make your own decision. So in Phoenix Extravagant the pigments in the magical paint are powered by the destruction of art. And I think it would actually be kind of difficult to meaningfully talk about this book without knowing that, because this book is all about the imperialist destruction and appropriation of culture. Because of course the occupying forces consider their own art too valuable to sacrifice to this cause when there is an abundance of ‘inferior’ culture that can be sourced instead. It’s a constant theme throughout the book even outside of a magical context. There’s a particular scene that sticks on my mind, when Jebi is walking through what was once the old dynastic palace of Hwaguk. They try to imagine the halls as they might have looked during the reign of the last ruling dynasty of Hwaguk, the Azalea Throne, ‘but Razan’s living presence overwhelmed their attempts to repaint the halls in their head’. In the opening scene we also see Jebi sitting an art exam, where they go through an internal monologue about what is likely to get them noticed and employed; they realise they cannot paint in the style of their own culture, but must adopt the schools of art favoured by their imperialist rulers if they’re to have any chance of succeeding. Yoon Ha Lee describes the different artistic styles beautifully as well. I consider myself a bit of a philistine when it comes to paintings; I really have to have them explained to me cos I just don’t usually get it, but I was really drawn in to these scenes.

I wasn’t really sold on the rest of the book though, I gotta say. Like, it was ok, definitely not a bad book, just not my thing maybe. I was very cool on the romance. It’s there to add some tension into the story obviously, because Jebi begins to have feelings for one of their Razani masters. Fine in theory, but it felt shoe-horned in to me at times, especially some of the sexier bits. There’s one particularly eye roll-inducing moment when the characters are in absolute mortal peril, Jebi is being untied by Vei (the love interest) and Jebi finds themself thinking whether the whole being tied up thing is ‘something they could explore later, after they’d escaped the Summer Palace and its hideous secrets’. And I dunno, I just thought, you’re potentially about to die and you desperately need to escape; is that really what’s at the forefront of your mind right now? Maybe I’m just a prude and I’m projecting my own thoughts on to Jebi. After all, it might not be what I would think about in that moment, but I guess it very well could be what Jebi does. Either way, in the moment I was just like *eye roll*. There were some good bits about the romance aspect though. I thought the tension between Jebi’s attraction to Vei developed well, especially as Jebi becomes more actively conscious of the role Razan plays as an occupying power in their society and over their culture. It’s summed up well when they realise ‘it was one thing to be attracted to Vei, and another thing to ignore who and what she represented’.

Also, if there’s one thing that came a close second in capturing my attention about Phoenix Extravagant, it was the motherfucking mecha dragon! Arazi is a giant automaton dragon brought to life by the magical pigments in it’s painted mask. There are rumours of a massacre involving Arazi, but Jebi becomes suspicious when the pigments used to instil particular behaviours in different automatons don’t line up with Arazi’s supposed involvement in the massacre. So they hatch a plan to break Arazi out of the complex and then things inevitably go south. Honestly though, I just wasn’t that interested in the giant mecha dragon, which feels like a bit of a low bar to reach. I’ll be honest, this might just be very particular to me, because the method of communication Arazi and Jebi adopt gave me traumatic flashbacks to Clef and Sancia in Foundryside, and I hated their stupid banter so much haha, so it might just be association bias.

This was a decent read overall, definitely worth it for the interesting use of magic as a way to discuss the imperialist destruction of culture. Maybe I’m just not very widely read, but I don’t think that’s something I’ve seen explored in fantasy before. I found the ending a bit bizarre and not particularly in keeping with the feel of the rest of the book; for a while I actually thought Jebi was talking metaphorically about what they decide to do at the end, but nope, it’s totally literal. So that was a bit odd, but I think most of the other things were just a writing style that didn’t grab me personally, but may very well be someone else’s cup of tea. Good book 🙂


Did you enjoy this review? Find it useful? Follow the blog and never miss a post!


9 thoughts on “Review: PHOENIX EXTRAVAGANT by Yoon Ha Lee

Add yours

  1. Ooooh, this is an excellent review for me (and why I always love hearing your take.) I’ve been waffling on this book for so long; I really enjoyed Ninefox Gambit, but there was something about this novel that made me wary. I could never put my finger on it. But all the parts you were cool on (and the eye-rolling romance) really tells me that this is NOT the book for me–which is too bad, because that magic system sounds super cool. But if you can’t get excited about a mecha dragon, well. I’ll need to give it a pass.

    A lot of people seem to have liked it though, so I’m pleased to hear that. Plus, that cover is so cool, I just love it. I’m excited to see what Yoon Ha Lee does in the future.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. It was the first Yoon Ha Lee book I’ve read and I’m still def interested in Ninefox Gambit even though this one wasn’t totally my thing. Glad this was helpful for you!

      Like

  2. You know, I didn’t really know what this was about before but now I’m super interested in reading it. Of course I do have some his other books in my TBR that I need to get to first so I should probably get on that haha.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This is excellent cos Rin’s response to my review was to make her realise the things that didn’t work for me assured her it probs isn’t the book for her either, but it’s actually convinced you you want to read it even though it wasn’t necessarily *my thing*. Who says middling three star reviews aren’t useful 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes, exactly LOL. Actually there’s this super popular YA reviewer on goodreads and anytime I see her hate a book I know I’ll probably love it so I’m like ‘and it’s going on my list’ hahaha. I think all reviews are useful if you know your tastes! 🙂

        Like

  3. Aww, that was my first review!

    Glad you felt it was worth reading for the magic system, at least! I think it’s a nice example of complex magic that doesn’t make the whole story about the magic.
    Totally know what you mean about the ending being out of place, but I quite liked it! (Possibly my favourite bit)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Was that really your first review? That’s weird, I feel like I only read it fairly recently. Maybe I missed it first time round and found it through a link floating around in the ether 😄 Yeah I def thought it was worth reading, but probs not gonna be the most memorable book for me.

      Like

      1. Yeah the earc came out about a year ago but the hardback much later, so I probably shared it then.
        Tbf now that time has passed I feel similar. But was an exciting time to get my first free book, and one with such an awesome cover!

        Like

  4. I’ve been super interested in fantasy books inspired by real-life colonialism lately, hadn’t realized that\s what this book was about, so definitely more interested now

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a website or blog at WordPress.com

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: